• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Reziero's NY Pizza

At Reziero's NY Pizza, we celebrate the heart and soul of New York-style pizza right in Tampa, Florida. Our journey started with a passion for authentic flavors, offering a menu that includes not only classic pizza but also scrumptious sandwiches and fresh salads. With a commitment to quality ingredients—like our housemade pesto and fresh burrata—we strive to deliver a rich dining experience. Customers rave about our generous portions and quick service, capturing the essence of a beloved NY pizzeria. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or enjoying our outdoor seating, we invite you to indulge in a slice of New York magic!

Reziero's NY Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Gia S.
Gia S.

best pizza in florida! closest thing to long island pizza! we order from here very often now.

Krista S.
Krista S.

This is a classic New York style pizza joint. They play all the greatest hits: Stromboli, Large pizza slices that don't flop, wings, subs, cannolis, you name it, they've got it. And it's good. Always great, quick service. The large portion sizes are also a plus.

Jennifer V.
Jennifer V.

Authentic NY pizza and subs at reasonable prices. Typical pizza joint ambience, which is fine by me. I love it when I can pop in!

Renee W.
Renee W.

Wonderful pizza. Love the veggie. This was our first time to order from this restaurant and it did not disappoint.

Jasmine B.
Jasmine B.

I'm giving a 4 because I feel like you can never expect a to go experience to be the best a restaurant has to offer, and my calzone was great. But we ordered delivery from there last night, and my husband's pizza seemed to have been cooked in the fires of Mordor. He could only eat about 1/3 of it and had to toss the rest. They also packed ranch dressing in the same box as this insanely hot pizza, so it was warm and gross by the time it arrived. I never understand when places pack salads/cold ingredients that way. Maybe we'll try again for dine in.

TiJuan R.
TiJuan R.

I read great reviews here on this place and decided to give it a try. I originally planned on going in to pick it up, but I saw it on DoorDash and ordered it there instead. I ordered the 1/2 16 inch. I got half supreme and half white pie. It was cool. It wasn't bad at all. I would definitely give them another try.

Orlando M.
Orlando M.

I've only had the pizza but I've heard great things about it, service is fast, and ambiance is a getting better.

Jamie S.
Jamie S.

My friend loves Reziero's and insisted I give the pizza another try so we did. I ordered a large pie, which was huge. The pizza was cooked perfectly and had the proper balance of sauce, cheese, and crust. The crust is still a little off for me, but that could be the Florida factor. Overall, it's still a great tasting pizza. I really like that the owner reached out to me. He clearly cares about his business and his product. Overall, Reziero is definitely one of the best options for pizza in South Tampa. Check it out!

Jessica G.
Jessica G.

We had a great experience here. My coworkers and I decided to stop by during lunch and enjoyed their 2 slice & a drink combo for 7.99. We also ordered wings, mozzarella sticks and a meatball sub. Everything was tasty and cooked well. The wings were huge, saucy and cooked all the way through. The meatballs and marina sauce were seasoned perfectly. I really enjoyed the bread they use for the sandwich. It was soft and chewy. The prices are very reasonable. We highly recommend stopping by. The manager and cooks in the back were all approachable with a great attitude. 5 stars!

Location

Welcome to the vibrant world of Reziero's NY Pizza, located at 5023 Bayshore Blvd, Tampa, FL 33611. This delightful eatery captures the essence of classic New York-style pizza, drawing inspiration from the bustling streets of NYC while offering a cozy and authentic atmosphere right in Tampa. With a diverse menu featuring salads, pizza, and sandwiches, Reziero's is a culinary paradise for food lovers.

One of the standout features of Reziero's is its dedication to quality and authenticity. Customers rave about the large, satisfying pizza slices that manage to hold their toppings without flopping—an essential trait of genuine New York pizza. Whether you’re indulging in their famous Stromboli, savoring a hearty sub, or treating yourself to a classic cannoli, every bite echoes with authenticity. Customer reviews highlight the superb taste and generous portion sizes, setting this pizzeria apart from the rest.

For those seeking a relaxed dining experience, Reziero's offers outdoor seating, where you can enjoy your meal alongside your furry friends, as dogs are welcome here! You can also opt for delivery or takeout, making it easy to savor their delicious offerings from the comfort of your home. And if you’re in the mood for a refreshing drink, choose from their selection of beverages, including popular soda options, beers like Corona and Heineken, or even a delightful glass of wine.

  • Location: 5023 Bayshore Blvd, Tampa, FL 33611
  • Phone: (813) 999-1781
  • Utilities: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor Seating, Dogs Allowed

While most reviews sing praises of Reziero's delectable offerings, there is an understanding that, like any restaurant, challenges can crop up in the delivery experience. However, the overwhelming consensus is that dining in at Reziero’s is the best way to truly appreciate what they have to offer. Each visit promises a warm, welcoming atmosphere paired with a burst of flavor in every dish.

If you’re searching for a slice of New York amidst the Sunshine State, look no further than Reziero's NY Pizza. Here, remarkable food, great service, and a nostalgic vibe remind you just how special a true pizzeria can be. Don't miss your chance to try it out; it might just become your new favorite spot!